Thursday, September 25, 2008

Teenage and Unwed Pregnancies




It's hard to go to work every day and see the things that I do and not be affected. I'm sure other people find themselves in this situation. There are a lot of careers that can wear emotionally on a person after some time, like, I don't know, prison jobs, counseling/therapy, or working with any underserved population. Sometimes I feel like I'm working against unbeatable odds. Can I really make a difference in the lives of the people I care for and counsel on a daily basis? Is there anything powerful enough to break the horrendous cycle in which some of my (young) patients are so deeply entrenched?



Kevin gets to hear a lot of my crazy stories. We commonly talk about how grateful we are to have been raised in the gospel, and how that single fact makes our lives so dramatically different from those I come across at work. We also appreciate that it's not only the gospel that has given us such an advantage over these women, but being raised by a mother AND father who taught us to value and respect the power of education, sobriety, sexual abstinence until marriage, civil obedience, and service to our fellow men. Those priniciples can be taught without any reference to religion or a higher power.


Maybe we midwives see a disproportionate number of disadvantaged women in our practice because we don't turn anybody away. We also have a lot of disadvantaged or teenage pregnant patients who come to us because their friends/family members referred them to us. We have a reputation for spending more time with our patients, listening to and acknowledging their problems and concerns, treating them with respect regardless of their situation or status, and offering support. Our prenatal visits range from 30 mins to 1 hour long because we believe in the value of spending more time educating our patients to prevent complications, rather than ushering them quickly through office visits to end up fixing problems later. Most busy OB practices allot 10-15 minutes for a routine prenatal visit. It's a smarter business move, but not necessarily better for the patient. I would estimate that over 75% of our pregnant patients are on Medicaid. I think it's important that the government provides a means for pregnant women to receive healthcare, but I think there is a staggering influx of pregnancies that end up being funded by tax dollars which could and should have been prevented.




Here's a snapshot of a few typical pregnant patients in our practice:




--A 15 year old girl who is an average teenager, states she has never drunk alcohol in the past, but last weekend her cousin (also a teenager, but already a mother) invited her to go to a party out of town with her. This girl makes a bad choice to try alcohol for the first time, gets drunk, and consents to have unprotected sex with a boy she had never met before. Now she is in my office crying because she's pregnant. She doesn't even remember the father's name and has no way to contact him. She's not ready to be a mother, but she's not going to get an abortion. One stupid decision on one night has changed her life forever.




--A 23 year old single mother of two gives birth to twins. Her two daughters are 4 and 2 and now she has two infant boys. She has myriad mental health issues including bipolar disorder and schizophrenia, but somehow manages to care for these four children, reporting only sleeping about 2 hours per 24 hour period. She was employed through a state assistance program with a desk job during her early pregnancy, but would continually not show up to work because it was "too hard on her body" to be sitting in a chair all day. She has complaints of chronic pain in her back, neck, and hips for which we referred her to a physical therapist. She is totally dependent on government and state assistance. She never finished high school. Her two girls and the twin boys were all conceived with different men, none of whom stayed around long enough to find out she was pregnant.




--A 19 year old woman comes in with her third pregnancy. Her first child was given up for adoption because the Department of Family Services deemed her unsafe to have custody of the child. She has a history of IV drug use and alcoholism. She has Hepatitis C. Her second pregnancy was an elective abortion because she was still using drugs and knew she would not be allowed to keep her baby. She is trying to turn her life around and has been sober for 6 months now. She is about 6 weeks pregnant at her first visit. Four weeks later, she states she would like an abortion. She broke her longest streak of sobriety and decided to stop going to her chemical dependency program. Two weeks later, after a domestic dispute with her ex-husband which was reported to police by her neighbors, she states she is moving to Illinois to live with her ex-husband's mother and is going to try to keep the baby. When asking us to fax her records to her new provider in Illinois, she states, "Don't send any paperwork or notes about my decision for abortion." What else does she plan to try to keep secret from these people in Illinois?




Now here are some statistics that I found in a little research I did yesterday. These numbers are from the Center for Disease Control's National Center for Health Statistics.


--After a 14 year downward trend in teenage (age 15-19) births from 1991 to 2005, there was a significant (3%) increase in the number of U.S. teen births from 2005 to 2006. Data from 2007 are still being compiled and analyzed and were not included in this report.


--Unmarried childbearing has risen 20% since 2000, and reached a record high in 2006.


--In the 25-29 year age group, unmarried births increased by 10% from 2005 to 2006.


What impact is this having on society? A classmate of mine at Georgetown did a lecture on teen pregnancy during our Master's program. In a 20-year retrospective study of children of teenage mothers:


--Children of teenage moms had increased rates of school dropout, depression, incarceration, and public assistance compared with children of moms aged 20 or older.




Are you starting to get a glimpse of the sad state of childbirth in our country? And teenage and unwed pregnancies are just one facet of the GINORMOUS problem. I'll probably post on a few of the other contributors in days to come.


This is such a difficult cycle to break. Most of my pregnant patients that come in with their first pregnancy at age 14, 15, or 16 are themselves daughters of teenage moms. A lot of their mothers were still children when they were born, so these girls were raised by their grandmothers. One great thing about grandmothers is that they have a tendency to spoil and/or not discipline their grandchildren. But when a grandmother is in the role of mother, the child seems to grow up under less supervision, less scrutiny, and is not taught about choice and consequences. The nurse that works in my office was raised by her grandmother and she said that is a very representative picture of her growing-up experience.


I don't know how much of a correlation there is, but the daughters of teenage moms also seem to engage in sexual activity at a very young age. Maybe it has nothing to do with the age of their mothers. It could just be a gradual cultural change. Most of my non-pregnant patients that come in for health screening or general health/gyn problems, when asked their age at onset of sexual activity, give an answer somewhere between 12 years old and 18 years old. Very VERY seldomly do I have a woman who tells me she initiated sexual activity after the age of 20. TWELVE YEARS OLD, people! Some sixth graders are twelve years old. By the time most girls here are getting to middle school, they are starting to have sex. By the time they're in high school, they and their friends are all getting pregnant.


Whenever my colleagues or I see a patient that comes to us for prenatal care who is married, planned pregnancy, and has at least one college degree, we take special care to mention it to the other providers in our office because it is such a rare thing. Of the 50 or 60 pregnant women I've met since starting work here, fewer than ten have been married. I can count the college graduates on one hand.


How are these girls going to learn to have respect for the power of procreation? I wish I could help them change their immature way of thinking, but that is a change that needs to take place in the home. I just don't see that happening here, now or anytime soon. These young girls are so flippant about sex. One of the most mind-blowingly immature conversations I have with teenage moms at their first pregnancy visit goes a little like this:




Me:"So was this a planned pregnancy?"


Girl and/or boyfriend: "No, it took me completely off guard."


Me: "So were you using birth control at the time?"


Girl: "No."


Me: "Condoms?"


Girl: "No."


Me: "So, this pregnancy was unplanned, but not prevented."


Girl and/or boyfriend get puzzled look on face at first, think for a second, then smile and say: "Yes! I never thought of it that way. That's exactly what it was."




HELLO??!?!? If you're having unprotected sex, you are asking to get pregnant. If you're having sex at all, you are opening yourself to the possibility that you will become pregnant. Even if you're using birth control, if you are engaging in sexual activity, you MUST understand that there is a possibility you can become pregnant. Where is the logic? Where is the OBVIOUS cause and effect chain of thinking? It's not there. Nobody is teaching these girls. The boys have also learned from society that it is okay to sleep around with multiple girls, dispensing sperm like candy, with no thought for repercussions and no sense of responsibility to their offspring.


I want to be involved in some sort of education program for these kids, but even that seems like it would be futile. They need their parents to teach them, but most of them only have one parent who is not even any more mature than the child is. It is so sad. We need to teach girls about the serious and life-long consequences of deciding to become sexually active at such a young age. When I hear the arguments for abortion and a woman's CHOICE, it screams to me that our society has it all wrong. The choice that a woman should be making is the choice of whether she is financially/emotionally/developmentally ready to bear and raise a child. If the answer is no, she should abstain from sex as this is the only 100% effective method of birth control. Sex is not a hobby, it is not an after school activity, it is a sacred power given to us from God through which we can create human life. Even if a woman doesn't believe in God, she should still revere the fact that her reproductive system has the power to nourish a human body and use it appropriately. A girl or woman who chooses to have sex needs to be taught the seriousness of the possible consequences. We need to reverse the rapid degeneration of the sanctity and/or gravity of the powers of reproduction.
Off soapbox.

11 comments:

richard dandelion said...

This is good stuff, Jamie. I wonder, though--it seems to put the responsibility for preventing pregnancies more heavily on women than on men.

Do you have any comments?

Shawn said...

This brings to mind a radio talk show host I heard a few years ago here in the Bay Area who said (regarding abortion), "These are smart, educated women. They should have the right to choose." The thought popped into my head, "If they're so smart, why are they dealing with an unwanted pregnancy?" I had sex for 17 years (don't picture that you guys) before my hysterectomy and never once had an unwanted pregnancy. (And you guys know that I didn't have 17 kids.) I know birth control fails sometimes but I think that can be and probably is used as an excuse for abortion too often. I think other reasons might be more the norm for getting pregnant when you don't want to, namely, the heat of passion or just not paying attention, etc.

I agree with JT. Good stuff, Jamie. About the responsibility thing.....I'm still thinking about that. I'd like to hear what others have to say about it.

Sherry Carpet said...

grim truths.

i hope it gives you some comfort, jamie, to know that what you do does make a difference. every woman (or girl) you treat with compassion and with whom you share your substantial education has been given a dear service.

i agree that learning to respect one's body is best taught at home. since these girls aren't getting that, are the montana schools at least teaching sex education? it doesn't sound like it.

Reianna said...

I am sorry that you run into so many patients who are not thinking about their sexual choices. I hope that as you get further in your practice as a midwife you will find more women who respect themselves and their bodies. I have met very few women who have used a midwife who fit your stereotypical patient. I hope that your passion for being a midwife is not diminished by all the sad stories that surround you. Know that there are people and places where women embrace the power of their bodies and use it wisely.
I have often wished I too could be part of some education process that helps teach men and women what power they have when they come together in way that is so sacred. I realize that the reason I respect my body and its powers so much is because that is how I was raised. Teaching children is the responsibility of the parent. I am just happy that I can do my part to raise good wholesome children who will hopefully continue to be respectful of their bodies. Thanks for being on your soapbox and working with these young girls who have so obviously lost their way. I am sure they find comfort in your sweet spirit.

Jamie said...

JT/RD: To hear you deem my post "good stuff" is quite flattering. Thank you! I think preventing pregnancy should be the responsibility of both men and women. I suppose my post made it sound like I think it's a girl's responsibility moreso than a guy's, but I was focusing on addressing the female side of the problem because it is the one I encounter at work.

Equally tragic stories exist on both sides. What a shame that so many men engage in sexual activity for sport or entertainment or gratification without thought for the life-changing and life-creating events that may and often do follow. Without thought for sexually transmitted infections, which increase women's risk for cervical cancer and decrease her chance for a normal vaginal birth. What a shame that women engage in the same irresponsible use of the reproductive powers without concern for the quality of life of the unborn child. Fault on both sides. Lack of education on both sides. Shame on both sides.

I think it's especially sad that so many men can just walk away from unintended pregnancies while the woman is left with nine months of vomiting, pain, stretch marks, hours upon hours of labor, possibly major abdominal surgery, and a lifetime of devoting herself to another human being that is (at least for the first several years) completely dependent upon her for survival. Sometimes I think it would be a good slap in the face for God to switch things up and make men the childbearers. Then they might think twice about how quickly, and with whom they decide to hop in bed.

Mom: Thanks for reading and commenting and for telling me you like my post. I agree that there are some pretty poor excuses for elective abortions, and that failed birth control is one of these. Every method of birth control has a failure rate even with perfect use. "Typical use" failure rates are even higher. For example, condoms are only about 85% effective with typical use, which accounts for the "I forgot just that once" or the "it was a heat-of-the-moment thing" or the "it broke" cases. We need to counsel people on these rates (and I do!) and if they decide to gamble and have sex anyway, they should not be surprised if they happen to be in the group of 15/100 people that get pregnant in a given year. Nowhere else do people get away with such shoddy logic.

SC: Thanks for the compliment. It does make me feel better. I don't know what the schools in our area are doing for sex education, but I'd be interested to find out. I'll add it to my list of things to do to distract myself from missing Kevin. :)

Jamie said...

Reianna: Thanks for the encouragement too! I know you're right. Funnily enough, the three places I have worked as a midwife (including student years) are Washington DC, Orem UT, and Butte MT.

There is a HUGE contrast to the patient population I saw in these three areas. Washington DC happens to not only be our nation's capitol, but also the nation's leader in HIV. The rate there is something like 4 times the national average. Most of my patients there were younger than me and had been pregnant at least three times, some girls as much as seven times, with most of those ending in abortion. Almost all unmarried, few had finished high school, mostly relying on government assistance. Sound familiar? The biggest difference between my pregnant patients in DC and my pregnant patients in MT is that when I was in DC, I had two white patients out of the hundred or so I cared for during school. In Butte, I have yet to even SEE a black person, and have only had a small handful of Native American or Hispanic patients.

In Orem, almost every single one of my pregnant patients was married, had a planned pregnancy, didn't smoke or drink, and faithfully kept all of their prenatal appointments. Not a big shock, I suppose. We were pretty close to three major colleges, so a lot of my patients were college students and were well-educated.

Such a stark contrast! It's obvious that those differences are thanks to the environments in which these young women grew up. It is a little overwhelming and frustrating to work among the patient population that I currently do, but I guess I can find some solace in thinking that these people need me a little bit more than my Orem patients did.

Carol Joy said...

Wow! Butte, Montana sounds a lot like the inner-city Omaha area! Talk about the high school I taught at! Sad, huh? You are too true in stating that it can so often feel futile! I hated that feeling.

But I know that people can't meet you and not have a change in their life. The fact that you care (and know) so much makes a difference! Even if it doesn't seem like it. And that's why it's hard.

Love to hear your soapbox messages!

annie said...

great post, jamie. i love your passion. every time you write i decide i'm going to be a midwife! :P please don't get off your soapbox. i learn so much every time you're on it!
i usually say i'm pro-choice, with the hope that people will choose life. but, auntie, your comment about the radio show gave me a new perspective. why, indeed, are all of these smart, educated women dealing with unwanted pregnancies? not to mention the examples they're setting for the next generation of women...
great thoughts everyone; i hope to see more!

Jana Brookes said...

So sad Jamie. All I could do was shake me head, while reading. I know it's just horrible, but even if you just change one life (which I know it's many more than that) that is ONE LIFE. I am sure that you are doing such an awesome job taking care of these girls that really do need you. I totally agree that it is a vicious cycle that you are trying to break, and that it should totally all be taught first in the home, and obviously isn't. I too, am so grateful to have been brought up right, and knowing that there are consequences to actions.
Keep up the great work. I do also enjoy your soapboxing!
6th grade. Yikes. That is Logan in five years. No way, no how! Rest assured she will be taught to abstain!

Hideaway Girl said...

Wow Jamie, I think it would be impossible to see this day in and day out and not have it wear on you emotionally. I only had to read your post to feel the overwhelming sadness of it all. Sad for the ignorant young parents, sad for the innocent babies being born, and sad because it is all preventable, yet these kids don’t seem to know how to do so. Who knows what kind of choices I would have made if I wouldn’t have been taught by my parents. What a difference that makes. Keep up the good work.

Nicea said...

I hadn't yet read this post when we had lunch yesterday after your bridals or I'd have commented on it then. You know that I teach an underserved population (Hispanic immigrants) at school. Every year I see sad cases of kids having kids. Last year a 14-year old student of mine got pregnant by a barely-15-year-old student of mine during the summer following her
8th grade year of school. She was excited about the pregnancy when she came to tell me about it and was going to marry the boy. He told me the same thing. His plan was to quit school and get a job. At 15!! The girl would visit me at school periodically throughout her pregnancy and when she finally had the baby, she was still with the boy--who didn't have a job--but had quit school. Several months passed and then just a couple of weeks ago, the boy showed up at my classroom door to say hello to me. He's barely 16 now, still not in school and still not employed. He was carrying a large sheet of sketch paper with a picture he'd drawn of a girl. I admired the picture and asked who it was. He told me it was his wife. Naturally I assumed it was the girl he'd fathered a child with, because it did look a little bit like her, but he told me it was a different girl. Just to illustrate the immaturity here, this boy asked me if he could stay in my classroom for awhile and borrow my colored pencils to finish his picture. (He wasn't even supposed to be on campus, let alone inside the school.) But somehow he'd managed to elude all the rules enforcers so I let him sit at a table at the side of my room while I taught my class, and he colored for the whole 85 minutes! When the dismissal bell rang, he put the colored pencils away, came over to me, showed me his picture and told me I could have it. I was stunned by the sheer childishness of his behavior in stark contrast to the very adult act of having sex and creating a child! All I could do was give him a hug, thank him for such a nice gift and tell him to come visit again soon. My heart just breaks for this kid. And the little mother is still living with her own mother and raising this baby without a father. I love these kids to death, but it IS overwhelming, like you said, and such a helpless feeling to feel like there's nothing you can do to turn the tide.